---
analysis-role: document-analysis
confidence-level: medium
confidence-rationale: The November angle pairs can be checked on the scans and the planetary positions independently reproduced. The pointing accuracy and observer clock error are unknown.
evidence-status: mixed
ai-analysis: true
accuracy-disclaimer: AI-assisted historical analysis. The astronomical comparison is a modern calculation and the attribution remains provisional.
ai-generated: true
companion-eligible: true
topic-slug: cajamarca-theodolite-readings-and-the-venus-comparison
topic-title: The Cajamarca Theodolite Readings and Venus
topic-description: Compare 57 timed directions recorded in Peru in November 1957 with the predicted position of Venus, then test the limits against the October reports.
topic-audience: serious-uap-readers
topic-priority: 8
---

# The Cajamarca Theodolite Readings and Venus

**Venus is a strong candidate for the light tracked on November 7 and 8, 1957.** At 57 times recorded at Kanzel Observatory, the predicted direction of Venus lies within 1.05° of the reported direction. The median separation is 0.50°. That agreement holds as the light climbs and moves across the sky on two afternoons. The October observations give a different result. [Observer’s account and first table](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=4) · [Continuation and November 8 table](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=5).

![Angular separation between reported directions and Venus by GMT on November 7 and 8, 1957](/media/Release_8/Analysis/images/cajamarca-venus-angular-separation.png)

*Calculated from the printed angle pairs and a modern ephemeris. Each point is one comparison. The chart shows angular disagreement and carries no implied instrument error bars.*

## Source Basis

The field report locates the observatory at 7°25′30″ S, 78°20′30″ W, 3,750 metres above sea level. The observer described a leveled Zeiss recording theodolite on a fixed concrete base. Another observer telephoned an approximate position on November 7. Only the observatory supplies a series of azimuth and elevation measurements. The call helps explain how the light was acquired, but supplies no second measured line of sight for estimating range. [Station and acquisition](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=4) · [Instrument mounting](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=5).

## Observation

The November 7 table begins at 17:43 GMT with azimuth 123.2° and elevation 48.6°. At 19:43 the readings are 156.8° and 69.3°. Venus moved through nearly the same part of the sky. At 18:10 on both days, the printed readings are identical at 127.0° and 54.2°. The corresponding Venus positions are 126.76°/54.62° on November 7 and 126.61°/54.46° on November 8. The repetition covers a moving direction and is more informative than an isolated match. Repeated rows from the same instrument share clock and alignment errors. They should not be treated as 57 independent confirmations. [Opening readings](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=4) · [Later and next-day readings](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=5).

| Date | Usable rows | Median angular separation | Smallest to largest |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| November 7 | 47 | 0.50° | 0.28°–1.05° |
| November 8 | 10 | 0.45° | 0.33°–0.88° |

**Calculation.** Use JPL Horizons observer tables for Venus at the printed station coordinates, with east-positive longitude −78.341667°, latitude −7.425°, height 3.75 km and airless apparent azimuth/elevation. Pair each printed GMT minute with the calculated direction for that minute. The separation is the angle between the two unit sight lines. Equivalently, its cosine is sin(e₁)sin(e₂) + cos(e₁)cos(e₂)cos(a₁−a₂), where e is elevation and a is azimuth. No fitted clock or pointing correction was applied. The last November 7 row at 19:47 gives azimuth 159.0°, but the final elevation digit is indistinct. It is the only November row excluded. [November 7 ephemeris](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&COMMAND=299&OBJ_DATA=NO&CENTER=%27coord%40399%27&SITE_COORD=%27-78.3416667%2C-7.425%2C3.75%27&START_TIME=%271957-11-07%2017%3A40%27&STOP_TIME=%271957-11-07%2019%3A48%27&STEP_SIZE=%271%20m%27&QUANTITIES=4&CSV_FORMAT=YES) · [November 8 ephemeris](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&COMMAND=299&OBJ_DATA=NO&CENTER=%27coord%40399%27&SITE_COORD=%27-78.3416667%2C-7.425%2C3.75%27&START_TIME=%271957-11-08%2017%3A40%27&STOP_TIME=%271957-11-08%2019%3A48%27&STEP_SIZE=%271%20m%27&QUANTITIES=4&CSV_FORMAT=YES) · [JPL observer-table conventions](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/horizons/manual.html).

## Why October stays open

October 26 is a visual account from the lake without a timed pointing. On October 28 the text equates 12:39 Lima with 18:39 GMT, while the following day’s entries use a five-hour difference. For October 28 we tested both 17:39 and 18:39 UT. The reported direction, 116°/44°, is about 7.75° and 21.08° from Venus respectively. The simultaneous Moon reading offers a clock check: its measured elevation is 30.2°, compared with predictions of 27.0° and 40.9°. The earlier time is closer on that check, yet still leaves a discrepancy. On October 29 the two directions also depart substantially from the prediction. The printed record does not justify correcting its clock until all dates fit a single identification. [October report and Moon check](/?open=Release_8%2FDOW-UAP-D202-Air_Intelligence_Information_Report_Peru-1957.pdf&page=4) · [Venus at the reported times](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&COMMAND=%27299%27&OBJ_DATA=NO&MAKE_EPHEM=YES&EPHEM_TYPE=OBSERVER&CENTER=%27coord%40399%27&COORD_TYPE=GEODETIC&SITE_COORD=%27-78.3416667%2C-7.425%2C3.75%27&QUANTITIES=%274%27&CSV_FORMAT=YES&TLIST=2436140.23541667%2C2436140.27708333%2C2436141.24375000%2C2436141.27708333%2C2436150.23819444%2C2436150.24444444%2C2436150.25694444%2C2436150.30069444%2C2436150.32430556%2C2436151.24444444%2C2436151.25694444%2C2436151.30069444%2C2436151.30972222) · [Moon at the same times](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/api/horizons.api?format=text&COMMAND=%27301%27&OBJ_DATA=NO&MAKE_EPHEM=YES&EPHEM_TYPE=OBSERVER&CENTER=%27coord%40399%27&COORD_TYPE=GEODETIC&SITE_COORD=%27-78.3416667%2C-7.425%2C3.75%27&QUANTITIES=%274%27&CSV_FORMAT=YES&TLIST=2436140.23541667%2C2436140.27708333%2C2436141.24375000%2C2436141.27708333%2C2436150.23819444%2C2436150.24444444%2C2436150.25694444%2C2436150.30069444%2C2436150.32430556%2C2436151.24444444%2C2436151.25694444%2C2436151.30069444%2C2436151.30972222).

## Working Assessment

The November series supports a planetary explanation more strongly than the original catalog summary alone suggests. The residual differences show why this remains a candidate identification. The file gives no pointing calibration against a known star for those sessions, clock error estimate or simultaneous measured bearing from another station. A calibrated reduction of the original recorder disk could test for a systematic offset. A synchronized second station showing appreciable parallax would weaken the Venus explanation. Neither range nor vehicle speed can be recovered from these single-station angles alone.

An earlier Air Force file documents a practical comparison. At Godman AFB in Kentucky, observers charted a daylight object's direction at one-minute intervals. The report credits a University of Louisville astronomer with identifying Venus. In the Utah and Montana film study, by contrast, analysts had to assume range to turn a projected displacement into speed. The Peru file is valuable precisely because the astronomical test can be performed in angles alone. [Godman theodolite account](/?open=Release_4%2FDOW-UAP-D094_Analysis-of-Flying-Object-Incidents-in-the-US_1949.pdf&page=21) · [Film study and assumed range](/?open=Release_5%2FDOW-UAP-D098_Film-Analysis-of-Unidentified-Objects_1953.pdf&page=8) · [Air intelligence field reports](/?open=Release_8%2FAnalysis%2FC142-Air-Intelligence-Reports-and-Witness-Estimates.md).

## November readings

The two direction columns give azimuth/elevation in degrees. Predicted angles and separations are rounded here. Use the linked observer tables for greater precision.

| November day | GMT | Printed direction | Venus direction | Angular separation |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| 7 | 17:43 | 123.2 / 48.6 | 122.76 / 49.11 | 0.59° |
| 7 | 17:44 | 123.3 / 48.9 | 122.89 / 49.32 | 0.50° |
| 7 | 17:45 | 123.4 / 49.1 | 123.01 / 49.53 | 0.50° |
| 7 | 17:46 | 123.6 / 49.2 | 123.14 / 49.74 | 0.62° |
| 7 | 17:52 | 124.4 / 50.5 | 123.94 / 50.98 | 0.56° |
| 7 | 17:53 | 124.8 / 50.8 | 124.08 / 51.18 | 0.59° |
| 7 | 17:54 | 124.9 / 51.0 | 124.22 / 51.39 | 0.58° |
| 7 | 17:55 | 124.9 / 51.2 | 124.36 / 51.59 | 0.52° |
| 7 | 17:56 | 125.0 / 51.4 | 124.51 / 51.80 | 0.50° |
| 7 | 18:03 | 126.0 / 52.2 | 125.58 / 53.22 | 1.05° |
| 7 | 18:06 | 126.4 / 53.4 | 126.07 / 53.82 | 0.46° |
| 7 | 18:07 | 126.6 / 53.6 | 126.24 / 54.02 | 0.47° |
| 7 | 18:08 | 126.8 / 53.8 | 126.41 / 54.22 | 0.48° |
| 7 | 18:09 | 126.9 / 54.0 | 126.58 / 54.42 | 0.46° |
| 7 | 18:10 | 127.0 / 54.2 | 126.76 / 54.62 | 0.44° |
| 7 | 18:11 | 127.2 / 54.4 | 126.93 / 54.82 | 0.44° |
| 7 | 18:12 | 127.4 / 54.6 | 127.11 / 55.01 | 0.44° |
| 7 | 18:13 | 127.6 / 54.8 | 127.30 / 55.21 | 0.45° |
| 7 | 18:14 | 127.8 / 55.0 | 127.48 / 55.41 | 0.45° |
| 7 | 18:16 | 128.2 / 55.4 | 127.86 / 55.80 | 0.44° |
| 7 | 18:20 | 129.0 / 56.2 | 128.65 / 56.58 | 0.43° |
| 7 | 18:25 | 129.8 / 57.0 | 129.69 / 57.54 | 0.54° |
| 7 | 18:26 | 130.0 / 57.2 | 129.91 / 57.73 | 0.53° |
| 7 | 18:27 | 130.2 / 57.4 | 130.13 / 57.92 | 0.52° |
| 7 | 18:28 | 130.4 / 57.8 | 130.36 / 58.11 | 0.31° |
| 7 | 18:30 | 130.8 / 58.2 | 130.81 / 58.48 | 0.28° |
| 7 | 18:33 | 131.2 / 58.6 | 131.52 / 59.04 | 0.47° |
| 7 | 18:35 | 131.6 / 59.0 | 132.01 / 59.41 | 0.46° |
| 7 | 18:38 | 132.4 / 59.6 | 132.77 / 59.96 | 0.41° |
| 7 | 18:39 | 132.7 / 59.8 | 133.03 / 60.14 | 0.38° |
| 7 | 18:42 | 133.4 / 60.2 | 133.84 / 60.68 | 0.53° |
| 7 | 18:46 | 134.6 / 61.0 | 134.96 / 61.39 | 0.43° |
| 7 | 18:49 | 135.2 / 61.6 | 135.85 / 61.91 | 0.44° |
| 7 | 18:59 | 138.2 / 63.2 | 139.07 / 63.59 | 0.55° |
| 7 | 19:03 | 139.6 / 64.0 | 140.48 / 64.23 | 0.45° |
| 7 | 19:05 | 140.4 / 64.2 | 141.22 / 64.54 | 0.49° |
| 7 | 19:06 | 140.6 / 64.4 | 141.60 / 64.70 | 0.52° |
| 7 | 19:11 | 142.4 / 65.2 | 143.55 / 65.45 | 0.54° |
| 7 | 19:13 | 143.0 / 65.6 | 144.37 / 65.74 | 0.58° |
| 7 | 19:17 | 144.6 / 66.0 | 146.07 / 66.31 | 0.67° |
| 7 | 19:20 | 145.8 / 66.4 | 147.41 / 66.71 | 0.71° |
| 7 | 19:21 | 146.4 / 66.8 | 147.86 / 66.85 | 0.58° |
| 7 | 19:23 | 147.0 / 67.0 | 148.79 / 67.11 | 0.71° |
| 7 | 19:40 | 155.2 / 69.0 | 157.59 / 69.01 | 0.86° |
| 7 | 19:41 | 155.8 / 69.1 | 158.16 / 69.11 | 0.84° |
| 7 | 19:42 | 156.2 / 69.2 | 158.73 / 69.20 | 0.90° |
| 7 | 19:43 | 156.8 / 69.3 | 159.31 / 69.29 | 0.89° |
| 8 | 17:52 | 124.3 / 50.0 | 123.82 / 50.81 | 0.87° |
| 8 | 18:00 | 125.2 / 51.8 | 124.98 / 52.45 | 0.66° |
| 8 | 18:03 | 125.8 / 52.2 | 125.44 / 53.06 | 0.88° |
| 8 | 18:10 | 127.0 / 54.2 | 126.61 / 54.46 | 0.35° |
| 8 | 18:25 | 129.8 / 57.1 | 129.51 / 57.39 | 0.33° |
| 8 | 19:09 | 141.6 / 65.0 | 142.43 / 65.04 | 0.35° |
| 8 | 19:13 | 143.0 / 65.6 | 144.03 / 65.63 | 0.43° |
| 8 | 19:16 | 144.2 / 66.0 | 145.29 / 66.06 | 0.45° |
| 8 | 19:20 | 145.9 / 66.6 | 147.04 / 66.61 | 0.45° |
| 8 | 19:26 | 148.4 / 67.2 | 149.83 / 67.39 | 0.58° |
